西部戦線異状なし

과연 누가 이상 없다고 말했을까

긴장감 하나만큼은 수작

누가 이상 없다고 한 것일지에 대한 관점

i was pretty on board with truffaut's anti-war quote, but now im not sure. its hard to see how much more anti-war this movie could get. "cycles" in this adaptation:
feeding the younger generation to the war machine again and again, reusing rousing speeches/patriotic rhetoric, and effectively replacing soldiers the same way they recycle their uniforms. one of the more cynical takes on war for sure, and it's refreshing (if I can even use that word) not to see an overly "hollywood" take on another pro-war film (see top gun). and the decision to end the war on the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month?? for the sake of poetic closure even though thousands died within those 6 hours? you can't make that shit up "modern warfare is like chess. it's never about the individual. it's always about the whole."

잔혹함은 잔인함에서 오지 않는다. 잔혹함은 잔혹함에서 온다.

전쟁의 참혹함…/

전쟁에 주인공은 없다. 허무한 전쟁의 참상을 여러 인물들을 통해 그려낸 수작.

허무한 전쟁터에 쌓여가는 갑작스러운 고요함. 전쟁에 두려움을 느끼게 한 무서운 영화..